SIRA — stable isotope ratio analysis
SIRA compares carbon isotopes. Sugars from C4 plants such as cane and corn leave a different signature than nectar from most flowering plants.
Since 2018, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) has bought and tested honey sold in or imported into Canada for foreign sugars such as cane, corn or rice syrup. Honey has a legal standard in Canada, so added sugar makes it adulterated.
CFIA — Enhanced honey authenticity surveillance (2018 to 2019)2018–19
Targeted sampling, 240 samples
52 of 240 samples failed one or both tests. Every domestic sample passed; every failure was imported honey.
78.3% satisfactory
2019–20
Targeted sampling, 127 samples (111 imported)
A separate marketplace check of 148 retail jars found 98% satisfactory. CFIA used both stable isotope ratio analysis (SIRA) and NMR.
86.6% satisfactory
2020–21
Targeted sampling
Honey was one of five high-risk foods in that year's fraud surveillance.
88.5% satisfactory
2021–22
Imported honey, 74 samples
17 of 74 imported samples failed. The Canadian Honey Council reports 184,921 kg of honey was detained, refused entry or destroyed that year.
77.1% satisfactory
2023–24
84 samples tested for foreign sugars
Honey had one of the higher authenticity rates among the foods CFIA tested that year.
CFIA — Food Fraud Annual Report 2023 to 20242024–25
Part of 886 authenticity samples across foods
Honey sat well below maple syrup (100%) and close to grated hard cheese (84%).
81% satisfactory
SIRA compares carbon isotopes. Sugars from C4 plants such as cane and corn leave a different signature than nectar from most flowering plants.
NMR reads a molecular fingerprint of the whole sample and compares it with reference honeys. This helps catch syrups that SIRA alone can miss, such as rice syrup.
CFIA aims these samples at higher-risk importers and products, so the failure rates describe the riskiest corner of the market, not every jar on a Canadian shelf.
Every failure CFIA reported in its 2018–19 study was imported honey. The results presented here are not broken down by country of origin or brand, so they say nothing about Yemen specifically.
CFIA — Enhanced honey authenticity surveillance (2018 to 2019)